A federal judge in Manhattan has refused to end a high-profile workplace harassment lawsuit against JPMorgan Chase, even after the bank argued that the former employee who brought it coaxed two people into giving false testimony.
The Ruling
On Wednesday, November 18, U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan denied motions by JPMorgan and one of its executives, Lorna Hajdini, to dismiss the case brought by former investment banker Chirayu Rana. The judge also turned aside their separate requests for sanctions. According to the court docket, those sanctions motions were denied without prejudice, which means they can be raised again once the case reaches a judgment or sooner if the court allows.
The order added that it should not be read as a view on whether evidence about the dispute could be admitted at trial.
What the Bank Argued
Rana’s suit, filed in the spring, accuses Hajdini of coercive and degrading conduct toward him and says the bank tolerated sexual coercion and racist remarks. JPMorgan and Hajdini deny the allegations, and Hajdini has countersued Rana for defamation.
In late October, the bank asked for the harshest penalty available, telling the court that Rana had pressed his sister, Chandani Rana, and a friend, Allan Flott, to swear to events they had not seen. Chandani Rana later recanted her sworn statement, saying she had never observed the conduct described. According to the bank’s filing, Flott has not retracted his account.
Why the Judge Said No
Kaplan said he had no way of knowing whether the sister’s original testimony or her retraction was the truthful version. Disputes like that, he wrote, are normally better handled by a jury than through lengthy side hearings on sanctions that distract from the main case.
The judge also criticized how the case has played out publicly, remarking that it had been fought in part as a public relations battle. He urged all sides to concentrate on preparing for trial or on persuading the court of the merits of their positions.
What Comes Next
The decision keeps alive Rana’s claims, the defendants’ denials and Hajdini’s defamation counterclaim. It does not decide whether any of the underlying accusations are true. The case has also been unsettled by changes in Rana’s legal representation over recent weeks, which adds uncertainty about its timetable. For now, the questions of who is telling the truth, and why a witness changed her account, are headed toward a jury.
Sources
- Reuters (via Investing.com): US judge rejects JPMorgan bid to dismiss lurid sexual harassment case
- Reuters (via Investing.com): JPMorgan says ex-banker Rana pushed sister, friend to lie
- Docket: Rana v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. et al. (S.D.N.Y.)
- Fortune: JPMorgan asks judge to dismiss ex-banker’s suit
